Ella. The story of the childhoods behind the Milburn Review.

—

by Civic Watcher

MEASURE WHAT MATTERS
Half an Hour of School a Week  ·  17 November 2026

Content Warning

This article contains accounts of suicide attempts and suicidal thoughts involving a child and young person. It has been prepared with regard to guidance on the responsible reporting of suicide issued by Samaritans.

If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this article, support is available:

Samaritans: call 116 123 (free, 24 hours a day, every day of the year)

Childline (for children and young people aged 18 and under): call 0800 1111 (free, 24 hours a day)

Shout: text ‘SHOUT’ to 85258 (free, 24 hours a day)

Measure What Matters on the Milburn Review

Half an Hour of School a Week.
And Who Was Refusing Help?

Alan Milburn’s review counts young people with special educational needs among those most likely to be out of work and education. It does not ask what happened when they asked for help.


Published: 17 November 2026  ·  Measure What Matters


On 5 May 2021, Ella’s school confirmed it could no longer meet her needs. By then she had been in hospital after a suicide attempt and was too unwell to attend. The family’s record of the meeting says all professionals agreed she was likely to need a small setting with specialist support. Twelve days later, at a meeting attended by a Local Authority inclusion officer and an educational psychologist, came the proposal for after half-term. Her mainstream school was perfectly sufficient. Half an hour of school a week.

Ella wanted to go to school. She kept trying to go back. Sometimes she managed only minutes. Her mother, Becky, had been raising concerns since Year 4. By the final term of primary school, staff acknowledged Ella “probably” had special educational needs. Becky recalls being told there was too little time left to gather the evidence for more support. It would have to be sorted out at secondary school.

Ella is autistic and has ADHD.

Ella was eleven when she first attempted to take her own life. She hadn’t even reached the end of the first term.


Alan Milburn’s long-awaited review, Young People and Work, is published today. Our special report instead sets out what we see behind that data: hundreds of thousands of children, broken by the education system. Milburn calls eighteen the “first major cliff edge” of disengagement, when the NEET rate rises to 13%. Yet most of the families we hear from would say their first cliff edge came in primary school. By eighteen, their children had gone over that cliff years before.

Milburn gets a good deal right. He rejects the idea that young people are lazy. His interim report had already found that young people with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) are around 80% more likely to be outside education, employment or training, or NEET, and called an education, health and care plan the “strongest single link” to that outcome at 17 to 19. By his own account, SEND ought to be central to any serious explanation of how young people get there.

Milburn writes, “Early disengagement is no longer a phase. It is sticky.” He counts the cost to the state of every month of inaction for a young person once classed as NEET.

But our question, and one the review determinedly does not ask?

Whose “inaction” are we actually talking about here?

The research Milburn’s review relies on records that a child with SEND, like Ella, had a Education Health and Care plan. It describes how simply being in receipt of this document, makes a child significantly more likely to be NEET at 17 yrs than any other cohort.

Yet the analysis tracks who has one. And goes no further. It therefore does not begin to consider whether the education and therapy in that plan ever arrived, the educational journey that child endured, and the consequences arising as a result.

Ella’s experience, along with the hundreds of testimonies we have analysed, now help reveal what that gap in understanding conceals.

Becky says their Local Authority refused to assess Ella’s needs on the grounds that her mainstream school could meet them. The very same school that clearly said it could not. This first refusal to assess her needs came at age 12, after multiple suicide attempts had already left her in a residential mental health facility. One she was technically too young to be allowed to access. The family challenged the refusal. The Local Authority conceded shortly before the hearing, after failing to evidence their decision for months. When the council eventually issued Ella’s plan, it again, against explicit professional advice, stated she would continue in mainstream education. The family appealed. Again. Eventually, two years on, a tribunal named a specialist placement. The placement that everyone had known, on 5 May 2021, she desperately needed.

Once there, Ella could finally learn. Becky says their Local Authority subsequently withdrew funding three times. The placement collapsed. Ella spent most of her secondary years without sustained access to suitable education. Even after a further tribunal in January 2026, Becky says core parts of her support are still missing.

And yet the research Milburn’s review relied on records only that a child like Ella had a plan. Nowhere in its many pages does it document or even consider the journey of that child through that support, or what of the education and therapy specified by that plan the child ever actually received.

…Or, the the irrevocable havoc and harm caused as a result.


What These Groups Share

Just look at some of the groups Milburn singles out as facing acute risk: young carers, care leavers, young mothers and young people who have offended. He acknowledges that almost a third of young carers have special educational needs. The same thread runs through the others. In England, 61% of pupils who had been in care for at least a year had recorded SEN in 2025, compared with 19% of pupils overall. Among children cautioned or sentenced for an offence, 80% had been recorded with SEN at some point in their schooling. Among adolescent first-time mothers with linked school records, 52% had a record of SEN provision.

Milburn treats these as four separate groups. He does not ask what they share. The answer to that question fundamentally changes the shape of the problem. What his report should say is that these staggering NEET figures are a devastating condemnation of the state’s failure to identify, assess and support children when they needed it. Worse? Not for lack of awareness. Our evidence says this:

They were not harmed by their need for support. They were harmed by how the state responded to that need.

Milburn himself acknowledges that disadvantages overlap. His graphs give separate entries to special educational needs, school absence, exclusion, mental health difficulties and low qualifications. They even examine how SEN and low qualifications interact. But follow just one child through those entries. Her school warns it cannot meet her needs. Her distress is read as behaviour and sanctioned. She loses teaching. Support is deemed necessary but withheld. Isolated, the gaps in her learning widening, her attendance collapses. Then she has no school place. Years later, the qualifications she missed appear in a review as a predictor of her prospects.

We ask – what qualifications did anyone expect Ella to gain on an offer of half an hour of school a week? On years without suitable education, on constant disruption to the little support she could reach, while her family buckled under the pressure of keeping her alive? And more importantly, what pathway to an independent future does Ella, aged 18, now have left?

Milburn’s report offers us statistic after statistic and graph after graph, each telling us where these young people are at one moment in their lives. It never owns the underlying issue: the difference between a child having evident needs throughout childhood, and what was done in response. The maladministration. The repeated obstruction of support. The pervasive denials. The unlawful decisions that came long before any young person finally gave up and disengaged.


The Childhoods Behind the Statistics

Ella is no exception. At Measure What Matters we have now analysed thousands of pages of detailed testimony from 1,706 respondents describing not just the outcome, but their families’ experiences of engaging with the SEND system in England.

These are the actual childhoods whose stories sit behind Milburn’s statistics. Yet his review does not examine them.


1,706
respondents
591
describe months, sometimes years, of severely disrupted education
354
accounts of no school place and no provision, at all

More than a third describe months, and at worst, years of severely, repeatedly disrupted education. 354 accounts explicitly refer to prolonged periods where they have no school place, and no educational provision at all. At least 305 accounts describe an authority discounting professional advice, or failing to act on the support professionals said a child needed. In at least 57 accounts, families describe an authority forcing a school to continue to retain a child on roll, after the school itself had explicitly confirmed it could not meet the child’s needs. For the child, this often looks like weeks and months of internal exclusion as the school literally struggles to keep that child safe. 58 families describe an assessment, plan, funding or provision still being denied after a tribunal had ordered it.

Families just like Ella’s. Hundreds, in fact, tens of thousands of them.

In most cases families describe how their child’s needs are already evident to professionals working with the child during their primary years, typically, at crisis point by 12 years old, then compounded by years of obstructive, unlawful denial of support by Authorities. In at least 101 accounts, the family could already identify serious concerns being raised by schools, requests for help or difficulties as early as key stage one. Some take us back to nursery.

The wider context? Parents give up work, forced to care for children spiralling into crisis. Earnings disappear. Pension contributions stop. Families are pushed into debt, paying thousands for private legal action to force authorities to comply with their legal duties, and funding emergency support for their children. Their financial security collapses. Alongside this acute financial impact, families describe exhaustion, rapidly deteriorating health, fractured relationships and siblings whose needs are soon crowded out by the struggle to secure help.


What “Failed to Interrupt” Leaves Out

Milburn asks adults to look for a young person’s strengths. Becky can tell him where to look.

In September 2025, an equine provision opened where Ella could attend regularly. She had received virtually no secondary education at all. It still took five years of legal action against the Authorities who held the legal duty to educate her to secure her a place somewhere she could learn. She is now eighteen, trying to rebuild her future. Becky remembers Ella saying:

“If I’m not worth educating, it’s not worth me being alive.”

Ella, as recalled by her mother, Becky

So here is her mother, just fighting to keep her alive. As Becky puts it:

“So we keep her alive. That’s it. That’s where we are.”

Becky, Ella’s mother

Milburn concludes his opening chapter by saying that disadvantage accumulates and the system “has failed to interrupt” it.

Given our evidence, we would ask you to now consider what that choice of words asks us to overlook.

A child in crisis. A council refuses an assessment. Suitable support is denied. Repeatedly. For years. Legal intervention finally secures a specialist placement. Funding is unlawfully, repeatedly withdrawn. Nearly a decade of a child struggling and seeking support. Each institutional decision not improving but further eroding their life chances.

Calling that a failure to “interrupt disadvantage” lets the people and the institutions who made those decisions quietly fade from the account. Ella? She has had to live with every one of them. And try to survive them.

For years, the state has knowingly withheld suitable education and support from acutely vulnerable children, and repeatedly denied it. In plain sight. It ignored warnings from families and schools, wilfully overrode professional advice, watched from the sidelines as each child fell into crisis and walked away, leaving their families to carry the catastrophic costs.


Tough Love

Breaking down barriers for young people who are desperately trying to get into work can only ever be a good thing.

But our concern is different. It is for those who cannot: young people left too unwell, too far behind, too isolated by what happened to them in education to take up an offer when it finally comes.

Today’s review announces change. But not the change Ella, or many of the million young people it counts, would expect from a state that neglected its duty to them for years.

It proposes that, on the day they turn 18, their inability to join the workforce should finally be considered a “crisis” now requiring shiny new legal provisions. In the sanitised, measured language of the powerful, it shifts focus away from the systems and decision-makers responsible for a decade of misconduct, and moves instead to judge and shame young people for the position they have been left in as a result of this harm. And where shame alone is insufficient, it would withhold their support as an incentive (read: punishment) for being left unable to take up work.

The real kicker? It even defines this as the “tough love” incentive they were clearly missing all along.

“But the deal’s a very straightforward one. If there are more opportunities for young people, there have got to be more obligations on their part to take up that opportunity. What we can’t have is a generation living on benefits. It’s a disaster for them, and it’s a disaster for the taxpayer.”

Alan Milburn, BBC, Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, 15 November 2026

So we have to wonder, how does Milburn define Ella now? If she is too unwell to take up an offer, who will establish why? Will anyone charged with judging her willingness to participate first have to consider what her school said on 5 May 2021, or explain who thought half an hour a week of education should suffice? Would Alan Milburn look Ella in the eye and remind her that opportunity comes to those who try?

There is a particular cruelty in a state that makes a child’s mother fight for years to secure any form of education or support, then entertains the idea that what her daughter may actually need at eighteen is the threat of losing her income. If ministers believe refusal should carry a penalty, let them begin by telling Ella what consequence followed for the adults and the institutions who refused her help. For nearly a decade.


She can already tell them what it cost her.

Tough love indeed.


Measure What Matters would like to express their gratitude to Ella, to Becky, and to all families who have shared testimony to support this work. We believe that the voice of lived experience must inform any meaningful reform.

The families represented here gave their testimony in the hope that it would matter.

We intend to make sure it does.


Measure What Matters are committed to handling source material with care, and to protecting the privacy of the children and families whose experiences are represented here.

Family testimonies are published at: measurewhatmatters.co.uk


Comments

Leave a Reply